Read Time: 1 Minute, 58 Seconds
What's up! Kyle here.
I was on a call last week with a dentist in the Upper Midwest. Good practice, solid reputation, been open for well over a decade. But the schedule had soft spots and new patient numbers had plateaued.
About halfway through the conversation he stopped me and said, "If this was your practice, what would you actually do first?"
I loved the question. So I gave him the real answer, not the polished sales version.
Here's exactly what I told him.
First thing I'd do? I’d call my own office.
I'd pull out my personal phone on a Tuesday at 2 PM and call the front desk like a new patient. No heads up. No warning. I'd pay attention to how many rings it took, whether I got a live person or voicemail, how I was greeted and whether the person on the phone made me feel like they actually wanted me to come in.
Then I'd do it again at 8 AM on a Monday. Then 4:30 on a Thursday. Then during lunch. I'd call from different numbers so they didn't recognize it.
Most practice owners have never done this. And most of them are shocked when they do.
The second thing I’d do, pull up my own website on my phone.
Not my laptop. My phone. Because that's how the majority of patients are finding you. I'd pretend I've never heard of my practice and ask myself one question. Would I book an appointment here? Is the phone number easy to find? Can I book online without calling? Does the site load fast? Do I get a sense of who the doctors are and whether I'd trust them?
If any of those answers are no, that's where I'd start spending money. Not on more ads. On fixing the thing the ads are sending people to.
Next, I’d look at my reviews and actually read them.
Not the star rating. The words. I'd look for patterns. Are patients mentioning the same team members? Are they talking about wait times, comfort, communication? Are the negative reviews getting responses? Are the responses defensive or professional?
Your reviews are the single most visible piece of marketing you have. They show up in Google Search, in AI results, in Maps, everywhere. If I owned a practice, I'd read every single one monthly and treat them like a free consulting report from my patients.
Then, I’d ask my front desk one question.
"When a new patient leaves after their first visit, what happens next?" If the answer is "we send them a reminder in 6 months," that's a problem. The window between their first visit and their second visit is where retention is won or lost. A follow-up text within 24-48 hours, a thank you message, scheduling the next appointment before they walk out, that's the system that keeps them coming back.
Lastly, I’d look at these numbers.
How many new patient calls came in last week? How many were answered? How many turned into booked appointments? How many patients are overdue for their next visit? If nobody can answer those questions quickly, that's the first thing I'd fix. You can't improve what you're not measuring.
I can tell you firsthand that your marketing can be incredible and you can STILL plateau if the internal conversion process is lacking.
That was my answer. No fancy strategy or expensive tools. Five things that cost nothing and take less than a week to evaluate.
His reply afterward?
"I have not done those."
Most haven't. That's an opportunity.
Talk next week.
— Kyle / Founder, Search-To-Seat™
Heads up! We are filling up on our Live Webinar on Thursday, June 11th at 7:00 PM EST. You can reserve your spot for $2 (the minimum Eventbrite would let me put) and I’ll be going over our entire system on how we drive new patients using Google and AI Search. You can reserve your spot here. You don’t have to interact, simply hop in the Zoom room and listen. No cameras or mics needed.

